Who can break their fast?
|It is allowed for those who are (not chronically) ill and for travelers to break their fasts during Ramadan, but they must make up the days they missed. Allah says in the Qur’an: “And [for] him who is sick among you or on a journey, [the same] number of other days.”
Mu’azh said: “Verily, Allah made the fast obligatory upon the Prophet by revealing: ‘O you who believe, fasting is prescribed for you as it was prescribed for those before you…’ until the words, ‘And for those who can fast [but do not] there is a “ransom” payment…’ Then, whoever wished to do so would fast and whoever wished to do so would feed a poor person, and that was sufficient for them.
Then Allah revealed another verse: ‘The month of Ramadan in which the Qur’an was revealed…’ to the words: ‘Whoever is resident among you during this month is to fast.’ [By this verse,] the fast was established for those who were resident and healthy. A concession was made for the sick and travelers, and the feeding of the poor by the elderly who could not fast was [left] confirmed.”
Related by Ahmad, Abu Dawud, and alBaihaqi with a sahih chain.
A sick person may break his fast which, if continued, would only aggravate the illness or delay its cure.
1) The wording of the verse is general and applies to all types of illness, and
2) A traveler is allowed to break his fast even if he does not need to and, therefore, the same must be the case for one who is sick.” This was also the opinion of al-Bukhari, ‘Ata, and the Zhahiri school of thought.
One who is healthy but fears that he will become ill if he fasts can break the fast, as can the person who is overcome by hunger and/or thirst and fears that he may die because of it, even if he is resident and healthy. He must make up the days of fasting that he missed. The following two Qur’anic ‘ayahs support this point: “And do not kill yourselves, Lo! Allah is ever Merciful to you,” and “He has not laid upon you in your religion any hardship.”
If a sick person fasts and withstands the hardships of the fast, his fast will be valid but disliked, for he did not accept the concession Allah gave him, thereby causing himself much hardship. Some of the companions would fast during the Prophet’s lifetime while others would not (that is if they were ill), thereby following the verdict of the Prophet.
Hamzah al-Aslami said: “O Messenger of Allah, I find within me the strength to fast while traveling. Would there be any blame upon me if I were to do so?” The Prophet, upon whom be peace, answered: “It is a concession from Allah. Whoever takes it has done well. Whoever likes to fast, there is no blame upon him.” This is related to Muslim.
Abu Sa’id al-Khudri reported: “We traveled with the Messenger of Allah to Makkah while we were fasting. We stopped at a place and the Messenger of Allah said: ‘You are coming close to your enemies. You will be stronger if you break the fast.’ That was a concession and some of us fasted and some of us broke our fasts. Then we came to another place and the Prophet said: ‘In the morning you will face your enemy. Breaking the fast will give you more strength.’ So we broke our fast, taking that as the best course of action. After that, you could see some of us fasting with the Prophet while traveling.”
This is related to Ahmad, Muslim, and Abu Dawud.
In another report, Abu Sa’id al-Khudri said: “We fought under the leadership of the Messenger of Allah during Ramadan. Some of us fasted and some of us did not. The ones who fasted did not find any fault with those who did not fast, and those who did not fast found no fault with those who fasted. They knew that if one had the strength to fast he could do so and it was good and that if one was weak, he was allowed to break his fast, and that was good.” This is related to Ahmad and Muslim.
The jurists differ over what is preferred (that is, to fast or not to fast while traveling). Abu Hanifah, ash-Shaf’i, and Malik think that if one can fast, he should do so, and if one cannot fast, he should break the fast. Ahmad said that it is best to break the fast. ‘Umar ibn ‘Abdulaziz says: “The best of the two acts is the easier of the two. If it is easier for one to fast than to make up the day later on, then, in his case, too fast is better.”
Ash-Shaukani has concluded that if it is difficult for an individual to fast or to reject the concession, then he shouldn’t fast (while traveling). Similarly, if one fears that one’s fasting during travel will look like showing off, then, in this case, breaking the fast would be preferred. If one is not faced with such conditions, then fasting would be preferred.
If a traveler makes the intention (to fast) during the night, he can still break his fast during the day. Jabir ibn ‘Abdullah reported:
“The Messenger of Allah left for Makkah during the year of the conquest [of Makkah] and he and the people with him fasted until he reached a certain valley. He then called for a cup of water, which he elevated so that the people could see it, and then he drank. Afterward, he was told that some people had continued to fast, and he said: ‘Those are disobedient ones, those are disobedient ones.’ ” This is related by Muslim, at-Tirmizhi, and an-Nasa’i. At-Tirmizhi called it sahih.
If one has already made the intention to fast while resident but then decided to travel during the day, the majority of scholars maintain that he must fast. Ahmad and Ishaq say that he may break the fast. This opinion is based on the report of Muhammad ibn Ka’b who said: “I came to Anas ibn Malik during Ramadan while he was planning on traveling. His mount was prepared for him, and he was wearing his clothes for traveling.
He asked for some food and ate. I said to him: ‘Is this a sunnah?’ He said, ‘Yes.’ Then he mounted his animal and left.” This is related by at-Tirmizhi, who called it hassan.’Ubaid ibn Jubair said: “During Ramadan, I rode on a ship with Abu Basra al-Ghafari from al-Fustat. He prepared his food and said, “Come [and eat].” I said: “Are we not still among the houses [of the city – that is, they had not left yet]?” Abu Basra asked: “Are you turning away from the sunnah of the Messenger of Allah?” This is related to Ahmad and Abu Dawud. Its narrators are trustworthy.
Ash-Shaukani contends: “These two hadith prove that a traveler may break his fast before he begins his journey. Of its credentials, Ibn al-‘Arabi says: ‘Concerning the hadith of Anas, it is sahih and proves that one can break the fast when he is prepared to travel.'” This is the correct position.
The type of travel that allows one to break his fast is the same as traveling which allows one to shorten the prayers. We have discussed all of the opinions on this point under the section Shortening the Prayers, and we have also recorded Ibn al-Qayyim’s conclusions on this question.
Ahmad, Abu Dawud, al-Baihaqi, and at-Tahawi recorded from Mansur al-Kalbi that Dihya ibn Khalifah traveled a distance of one farsakh during Ramadan. When he broke his fast, some of the people accompanying him did likewise. Some of them did not agree with this action. On his return to his city, Dihya said: “I saw something today that I did not suspect I would ever see. The people turned away the Messenger of Allah’s guidance and that of his companions.” He said that about the people who had fasted. Then he said: “O Allah, take [my soul] to you.” All of its narrators are trustworthy, except for Mansur al-Kalbi… although al-‘Ijli affirms his credibility.
Those who must make up the missed days
The scholars agree that it is obligatory for menstruating women and women with post-childbirth bleeding to break the fast and to make up the missed days later on. Al-Bukhari and Muslim recorded that ‘Aishah said: “When we would have our menses during the lifetime of the Prophet, we were ordered to make up the days of fasting that we had missed but were not ordered to make up the prayers that we had missed.